Featured Images

NHS outsourcing contract collapses due to ‘catalogue of failures …

A “catalogue of failures” resulted in the collapse of an £800 million NHS contract to outsource care of older and mentally ill people, the Commons spending watchdog warned.

An influential committee of MPs concluded that the NHS lacked expertise in procurement and it was “worrying” that untested contracting arrangements could form part of the plans being drawn up for further changes to services across England.

The Public Accounts Committee was scathing about the doomed deal between Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) and UnitingCare Partnership, which collapsed after just eight months.

The cash-strapped CCG awarded a five-year contract to UnitingCare, an NHS consortium of Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, but the deal was scrapped in December 2015 after it ran into difficulties.

The MPs said: “The procurement exercise was undermined from the start by poor commercial expertise, a lack of realistic pricing, and weak oversight.

“The CCG accepted the lowest bid on the table, without seeking proper assurance that the two trusts, which had combined to form the UnitingCare Partnership, could deliver for that price.

“It was then grossly irresponsible of the trusts and the CCG to rush ahead with the contract without having resolved significant differences in their understanding of the contract price or indeed the scope of services that were included in that price.”

In a strongly-worded report the committee said the “astonishing array of errors” in the contract showed that the health sector was not “getting the commercial basics right”.

The committee called on NHS England and NHS Improvement to ensure that safeguards are put in place to avoid similar problems in the wave of changes currently being planned.

Health managers in 44 areas of England have been ordered to draw up sustainability and transformation plans (STPs), setting out how they will reduce costs, change services and improve care in the wake of a record £2.45 billion deficit.

  • 1/32

    13 November 2016

    Queen Elizabeth II lays a wreath during the annual Remembrance Sunday Service at the Cenotaph on Whitehall in London, England

    Getty

  • 2/32

    13 November 2016

    The Prince of Wales arrives at the Guards’ Chapel in Wellington Barracks, London for a service and to lay a wreath at the Guards’ Memorial for the Welsh Guards’ Regimental Remembrance Sunday

    PA wire

  • 3/32

    13 November 2016

    British Prime Minister Theresa May, Jeremy Corbyn Leader of the Labour Party and Angus Robertson, Deputy Leader of the Scottish National Party with former British Prime Minister’s David Cameron, Tony Blair and Sir John Major during the Remembrance Sunday ceremony at the Cenotaph in London, Britain

    EPA

  • 4/32

    13 November 2016

    Prime Minister Theresa May, Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, Liberal Democrats leader Tim Farron, and Westminster Leader of the Scottish National Party Angus Roberston take part in the Remembrance Sunday ceremony at the Cenotaph in Westminster, central London

    Reuters

  • 5/32

    13 November 2016

    Veterans wait on Horse Guards Parade for the start of the Remembrance Sunday ceremony at the Cenotaph in Westminster, central London

    Reuters

  • 6/32

    13 November 2016

    People across the UK gathered to pay tribute to service personnel who have died during conflicts, as part of the annual Remembrance Sunday ceremonies

    ge

  • 7/32

    13 November 2016

    Members of Scotland’s armed forces and veterans gather to commemorate and pay respect to the sacrifice of service men and women who fought in the two World Wars and subsequent conflicts in Fort William, Scotland

    Getty

  • 8/32

    12 November 2016

    The 689th Lord Mayor of the City of London Andrew Parmley waves from his carriage during The Lord Mayor’s Show

    Getty

  • 9/32

    12 November 2016

    The Lord Mayor procession passes by St Pauls Cathedral in London

    EPA

  • 10/32

    12 November 2016

    Spectators watch as the Lord Mayor of the City of London’s carriage arrives outside the Royal Courts of Justice during the Lord Mayor’s Show in London, England

    Getty

  • 11/32

    12 November 2016

    The Lord Mayor’s Show, now in its 801st year, makes its way from the City of London to the Royal Courts of Justice today in a display of pageantry featuring a 6,500 strong procession

    Getty

  • 12/32

    12 November 2016

    Participants of the Lord Mayor’s Show parade past St Paul’s Cathedral

    Getty Images

  • 13/32

    9 November 2016

    Dr. Christopher Moran, Chairman Co-operation Ireland, Arlene Foster, First Minister of Northern Ireland, Queen Elizabeth II, Martin McGuinness, Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland and Frances Fitzgerald, Minister of Justice and Equality Gov of Ireland, attend a Co-Operation Ireland Reception at Crosby Hall in London, England. During the reception The Queen unveiled a portrait of herself by artist Colin Davidson

    Getty

  • 14/32

    9 November 2016

    Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May visits the Someshwara Swamy temple in Bengaluru, India

    Reuters

  • 15/32

    9 November 2016

    Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May receives a souvenir from officials during her visit to the Someshwara Swamy temple in Bengaluru, India

    Reuters

  • 16/32

    9 November 2016

    Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May stands among Indian school children as they watch a fly-past by Indian Airforce planes during a visit to a school on the outskirts of Bangalore

    Getty

  • 17/32

    9 November 2016

    Heavy snow in Tow Law, in County Durham, after wintry weather swept across northern England

    PA wire

  • 18/32

    8 November 2016

    Seaham Lighthouse in Co Durham as a gap in the cloud lets the sun through

    PA wire

  • 19/32

    8 November 2016

    A photographer captures the sun as it rises over the Vale of Pewsey in Wiltshire

    PA wire

  • 20/32

    8 November 2016

    A low mist covers the fields as the sun rises over the Vale of Pewsey near to Marlborough in Wiltshire

    PA wire

  • 21/32

    7 November 2016

    Remembrance poppies added to parent and child parking bays outside a Sainsbury’s store in Uxbridge

    PA wire

  • 22/32

    7 November 2016

    Street artist Pegasus adds remembrance poppies to parent and child parking bays outside a Sainsbury’s store in Uxbridge.
    He was commissioned by the supermarket to adorn the symbols across 22 stores around the country to mark their 22-year partnership with the Royal British Legion. To date, Sainsbury’s has raised over £30 million for the charity’s Poppy Appeal, helping provide vital care to past and present members of the armed forces

    PA wire

  • 23/32

    7 November 2016

    A replica landscape of the planet Mars is unveiled in London’s Trafalgar Square, including the Mars Rover prototype ‘Bridget’, to mark the launch of new National Geographic television series ‘MARS’

    PA wire

  • 24/32

    7 November 2016

    A replica landscape of the planet Mars is unveiled in London’s Trafalgar Square

    PA wire

  • 25/32

    7 November 2016

    Toby Campbell, eight, interacts with a replica landscape of the planet Mars is unveiled in London’s Trafalgar Square, including the Mars Rover prototype ‘Bridget’, to mark the launch of new National Geographic television series ‘MARS’

    PA wire

  • 26/32

    7 November 2016

    The scene outside Bedford Prison after a riot which reportedly saw up to 200 inmates go on the rampage.
    The disturbance was successfully resolved after riot officers spent more than six hours trying to bring the disorder under control

    PA wire

  • 27/32

    6 November 2016

    Participants drive their vintage cars past Westminster Bridge during the annual London to Brighton veteran car run in London

    Reuters

  • 28/32

    6 November 2016

    Participants drive their 1900 Cleveland electric, down the Mall in front of Buckingham Palace during the London to Brighton Veteran Car Run in London

    AP

  • 29/32

    4 November 2016

    Dancers pose as characters from The Nutcracker, for the annual Christmas event at Chatsworth House near Bakewell in Britain

    Reuters

  • 30/32

    4 November 2016

    Dancers Alice Rathbone and Daisy Edwards as characters from The Nutcracker

    Reuters

  • 31/32

    4 November 2016

    Dancer Daisy Kerry poses as the Snow Queen from The Nutcracker

    Reuters

  • 32/32

    4 November 2016

    Dancers Alice Rathbone and Daisy Kerry pose as characters from The Nutcracker, for the annual Christmas event at Chatsworth House near Bakewell in Britain

    Reuters

The MPs said that the “elaborate” UnitingCare deal “exposed gaps in regulatory and oversight arrangements” which could reoccur in local initiatives proposed as part of STPs.

The committee has already warned the NHS that it needed to improve its commercial skills but the UnitingCare fiasco showed it “still lacks the expertise to ensure that patient services are procured effectively”.

“This is all the more worrying as local initiatives proposed in sustainability and transformation plans may still include CCGs using new or untested contracting arrangements.

“With the NHS budget so stretched, innovative solutions are likely to be part of attempts to make the NHS financially sustainable.

“NHS England and NHS Improvement must improve the oversight and supervision of contracting arrangements and avoid such catastrophic failures in future.”

The Public Accounts Committee found that the termination of the contract led to unfunded costs of least £16 million, which had to be shared between the two NHS trust partners and the CCG.

The committee’s Labour chairwoman Meg Hillier said: “It beggars belief that a contract of such vital importance to patients should be handled with such incompetence.

“The deal went ahead without parties agreeing on what would be provided and at what price – a failure of business acumen that would embarrass a child in a sweet shop, and one with far more serious consequences.

“Services for patients are likely to suffer and we will be expecting the clinical commissioning group to come clean about precisely how much damage has been done in terms of future service provision and finances.”

She said it was understandable that health chiefs were looking for new ways of providing services but “what is not acceptable is for services to be farmed out to the lowest bidder without due regard for the interests of patients and taxpayers in general”.

Press Association

  • More about:
  • NHS
  • CCG

Article source: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/nhs-outsourcing-contract-catalogue-of-failures-older-mentally-ill-a7419771.html

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>